Home  >  Opinion

It's lose-lose for Maria Chin and PH

  • Civic organizations can accomplish campaigns political parties are unable to. It is suicidal for PH to bring Bersih under its own wing!

Sin Chew Daily

Pakatan Harapan appears to be unaware that one of its biggest assets has been Bersih, not Maria Chin Abdullah.

Similarly, Maria doesn't seem to know that her platform should be Bersih, not Pakatan Harapan.

So, when Maria quit as Bersih 2.0 chairperson to run for election under PH, the decision has sealed a lose-lose destiny for both PH and Maria.

It doesn't matter how she is defending her decision, or how much support she gets from Bersih leadership and fans, her decision is a kind of abandonment or even betrayal for many who once embraced Bersih.

This comes as a heavy price the Bersih campaign has to pay.

Bersih is a civic organization, not a political party. It is engaged in a civic movement, not political activities. It has a remarkable following by virtue of its noble position unbound by politics. This explains why Bersih has managed to galvanize hundreds of thousands of people to take to the street.

The rakyat were sick of political power play and completely battered by the greed of political leaders. This is why they were willing to join Bersih rallies and not political ones.

Malaysians used to support Maria Chin, approved her aspirations and ideals, and would follow her footsteps. But, the moment she is clad in the colors of Pakatan Harapan, her civic movement aura is wholly depleted, frustrating her erstwhile followers who now think they have been betrayed or even exploited by her.

And the price goes beyond her to Bersih. If even a Bersih leader can abandon the course, how is it going to get the public to continue supporting it?

While PH appears to have gained from the move, it has actually lost.

In the past, it used to trail behind Bersih and reap the fruit from Bersih's effort.

The first Bersih rally in 2007 brought sky high expectations for fair elections among the rakyat as well as frustration towards the ruling coalition among undecided voters. Thank to the rally, Pakatan Rakyat successfully took down a large number of BN seats in the general elections the following year.

The subsequent rallies in 2011 and 2012 sent the urban voters' anti-BN sentiment to unprecedented levels, helping Pakatan Rakyat capture several more urban and mixed constituencies in the 2013 elections.

Pakatan Rakyat would not have gone this far if not for the boost from Bersih rallies.

Even with its lackadaisical showing at the 2015 rally, Bersih remained the most influential civic organization in the country.

What PH doesn't seem to understand is that civic organizations can accomplish campaigns political parties are unable to. They help attract votes that political parties themselves fail to get. It is suicidal for PH to bring Bersih under its own wing!

PKR doesn't really need Maria Chin to help win an additional parliamentary seat. Whether she eventually runs in PJ Selatan or Selayang, her chances of winning are exceptionally good, but to be honest, PKR can win just as robustly in these constituencies irrespective of the candidates fielded.

As such, Maria Chin will not boost the number of PKR's seats in the end.

Nevertheless, when the rakyat begin to feel disenchanted by PH, it may surrender some of its narrowly won seats this time.

While PH has won a Maria Chin, it will lose a super civic platform that is Bersih 2.0, and while Maria Chin Abdullah may gain a Yang Berhormat title, she has relinquished all the pledges she once made to the civic campaign as well as the trust placed on her by the civic society.


Copyright © 2019 Sin Chew Media Corporation Berhad (98702-V).
All rights reserved. Contact us : [email protected]